The Reds have seen a decent amount of players remain with the team since they were in Whitehouse. These include:
​
-
Matt Sommo – Manager/1B/OF/P
-
Sal Nesto – Assistant Manager
-
Billy Holden – 1B
-
Mike Diacont – C
-
Tom Pavero – IF/P
-
Nick Potouridis – OF/P
-
Carlo Romano – OF/P
-
Chris Savarese – IF/OF
-
Jon Sanchez – C/IF
-
Brett Revet – IF/OF/P
-
Dave DeRosa – OF
-
Matt Nesto – IF/C
-
Mike Nasto – OF/2B
-
Nick Sommo – P/IF
2004 Tommie Agee League Summer Champions
14-1 (10-0 / 4-1)
​
2009 Tommie Agee League Summer Champions
11-4 (7-3 / 4-1)
​
​The New Providence Reds were formerly known as the "Whitehouse Reds" and were a part of numerous leagues before finding a home in the NJABL in the spring of 2013.
​
-
Tommie Agee League (68-26)
-
Summer 2004: 14-1 (10-0 / 4-1)
-
Summer 2005: 9-3 (8-2 / 1-2)
-
Summer 2006: 10-4 (8-2 / 2-2)
-
Summer 2007: 9-6 (5-5 / 4-1)
-
Summer 2008: 5-5 (5-5 / 0-0)
-
Summer 2009: 11-4 (7-3 / 4-1)
-
Summer 2010: 10-2 (9-1 / 1-1)
-
​
-
Billy Miller League​ (16-8)
-
Fall 2004: 11-3 (9-1 / 2-2)
-
Fall 2011: 5-5​ (5-4 / 0-1)
-
​
-
Duke Snyder League​ (29-19)
-
Fall 2009: 8-4 (7-2 / 1-2)
-
Fall 2010​: 6-6 (5-4 / 1-2)
-
Spring 2011: 15-9 (13-7 / 2-2)
-
​
-
Adult Baseball League of New Jersey (18-15)​
-
Spring 2012: 18-15​ (16-14 / 2-1)
-
​
Overall
131-68 (.658)